What to say when he admits he's talking to others too
He's being honest about juggling matches. How to respond without playing games, getting defensive, or pretending you don't care.
He's told you he's actively messaging other people on the app. This is him being transparent rather than sneaky, which is actually a good sign. But it can feel like a rejection or a test of whether you'll compete for his attention.
Your reply sets the tone for what comes next. It signals whether you understand how dating apps work, can handle direct conversation, and are interested enough to keep talking without needing promises he's not giving yet.
The goal is not to convince him you're better than his other matches. It's to show you're comfortable with reality, keep the momentum going, and let him see why he'd want to focus on you eventually.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeHe's actually being direct, not rejecting you
When someone tells you they're talking to multiple people, they're usually doing the opposite of playing games. He could have just kept that quiet. The fact that he said it means he either doesn't want to lie to you or he's checking whether you can handle it. Both are better than silence.
What this is not. A sign you're not his top choice yet. You've just met. Nobody's top choice after a few messages. What it is. Him being honest about where things stand. Most people don't do this. Most people just fade when someone else becomes more interesting. He's giving you real information instead.
Show you get how this actually works
Your reply should acknowledge that this is just how dating apps function. You don't need to pretend you weren't also talking to others or that you're now going to delete every match out of loyalty. You also don't need to overcorrect by bragging about your other options.
The move is to match his directness. Keep it short. Show you're unbothered by the reality of app dating. Then pivot to the actual conversation, not the logistics of his message inbox. Let him see you're worth focusing on by being the person who doesn't need constant reassurance or games.
Send it same day, then let him carry the thread
Reply within a few hours while the conversation is still live. Don't overthink the timing as a strategy. After you respond, stop steering the conversation toward exclusivity or reassurance. Let him drive things forward if he's interested.
If he goes quiet after your reply, that's your answer about where his interest actually sits. Don't follow up trying to win him back. If he keeps messaging, good. That's when you can start to see if there's real momentum. Give it at least a week of regular conversation before you even think about the talking-to-others piece again.
Why these replies fail
“lol honestly i'm talking to like 5 other guys right now so no worries. you're in competition buddy”
It turns the conversation into a competition and comes off as defensive, even if you're trying to seem unbothered.
“oh... ok. let me know when you decide who you want to actually focus on then”
This is passive aggressive and shuts down the conversation instead of letting it develop naturally.
“that's fine, but just so you know i'm only talking to you, so whenever you're ready to do the same just let me know”
It puts pressure on him to match your exclusivity and makes it weird by introducing a condition he hasn't asked for.
Common mistakes
- Getting defensive and listing your own matches to prove you have options too
- Pretending his honesty doesn't bother you when it does, then ghosting later
- Asking him to stop talking to others or cut things off with them
- Matching his energy too hard by saying you're super busy talking to others too
- Going cold or pulling back as a punishment for his honesty
Questions people ask
- Does him telling me this mean he's not that interested?
- Not necessarily. Early on, everyone's talking to multiple people. What matters is whether he keeps messaging you, makes plans, and gradually stops talking to others because he's more into you. His honesty is actually a sign he respects you enough not to lie.
- Should i ask him to stop talking to others?
- No. You've just met. That's not your call to make. If things progress and you've been seeing each other for a few weeks, you can have the exclusivity talk. Right now, asking makes you look like you're moving faster than he is.
- What if i was lying and i'm only talking to him?
- Don't tell him that. It's true, but it's not his business yet, and it changes the dynamic. Just respond naturally to what he said without oversharing your own dating life. Focus on whether he's worth your time by watching how he acts going forward.
- Is it a red flag that he brought this up unprompted?
- No. It could actually mean he's been burned before by miscommunication or he's just trying to be respectful. Some people lead with honesty about this. It's not a red flag unless his behavior contradicts what he said later.
What people say after using WingAI
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
“I'm busy and half the profiles give you almost nothing to work with. WingAI gets me a solid first line fast without me staring at the screen for ten minutes.”
Ralph
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free